Staying Safe while taking Acetaminophen
Did you know that your medicine cabinet might contain a potentially dangerous medication?
This medicine is a pain and fever reducer that many people take regularly. Its' generic name is acetaminophen, but you may know it by its brand name: Tylenol®.
When taken correctly, acetaminophen is very safe; however, it can be extremely dangerous when more than the recommended amount is taken.
I recently saw a patient in the hospital who took two medications for a headache that would not go away. Her headache soon became the least of her worries as she was admitted to the hospital for an acetaminophen overdose.
This patient was confused about why the overdose happened because she only took two different products to help her headache. Unfortunately, both products contained acetaminophen and the combined amounts were greater than the recommended daily dosage.
What other medicines contain acetaminophen?
The drugstore shelves are filled with products like Tylenol®, Goody's® Powder, Excedrin®, Cetafen, and other non-prescription medicines that contain acetaminophen. So, overdoses with acetaminophen products can happen by accident.
How can such a commonly used medication be so problematic? Taking acetaminophen in amounts that exceed the recommended daily dose can cause permanent liver damage. In 2005, the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases reported that acetaminophen overdoses had become the leading cause of acute liver failure in the United States. Also, children less than 12 years of age need to use lower doses, and people with liver problems may need to use a lower maximum dose or avoid using the product entirely.
Related questions
- What's the best medicine for sore throat?
- Acetaminophen vs paracetamol: What do you need to know?
- What is paracetamol / Panadol called in the US?
How do so many overdoses of acetaminophen happen?
If maximum daily doses and instructions for use are on the product's label, how do so many overdoses happen? As mentioned above, acetaminophen is found in a number of non-prescription and prescription products used to treat a variety of conditions.
For example, a person with a headache may take two tablets of Extra Strength Tylenol® for pain relief. At the same time, he or she may take a dose of DayQuil® for relief of their cold and flu symptoms.
He or she has now taken almost half the maximum daily dose of acetaminophen in a matter of seconds. If this person continues to take the medicines throughout the day at recommended intervals, he or she could easily find themselves in the emergency room… all because of a headache and the sniffles! Acetaminophen overdose can be fatal and may require hospital treatment to reduce the risk of permanent damage or death.
Summary
The moral of the story is this: Check every label for the appropriate dose, remember the daily maximum limit, and do not take two or more products that contain acetaminophen at the same time without checking first with your doctor or pharmacist. Seek help immediately if you suspect that you've accidentally taken too much. Just because a medicine is non-prescription doesn't mean that it's risk-free.
Still have questions? Be sure to ask your pharmacist. They are there to help!
Related medical questions
- Can I take Meloxicam and Aleve or Tylenol together?
- Is Tylenol (acetaminophen) a blood thinner?
- Is acetaminophen (Tylenol) an NSAID Drug?
- Can I take Tylenol while pregnant?
- Does Tylenol cause autism, what do the studies say?
- How long does it take for Tylenol to start working?
- Can I take cyclobenzaprine and Tylenol together?
- Is acetaminophen the same as Tylenol?
- Is Tylenol (acetaminophen) an NSAID?
- Can I give my dog or cat Tylenol (acetaminophen)?
- OTC Water Pills
- Can I take Tylenol while taking indomethacin and can these drugs be alternated every 3 hours?
- Is Tylenol (acetaminophen) an anti-inflammatory drug?
- Over the Counter Medication for Pets
- How do I treat back pain without using opioids?
- How Can I Treat Muscle Strain or Pain?
- Can Tylenol (acetaminophen) cause bruising?
- Why do drugs have brand names and a generic name?
- High blood pressure or heart disease: Which drugs should I be careful with?
- What should you keep in your medicine cabinet for kids?
- Can I use Tylenol for dengue fever?
- I have Monkeypox (Mpox): What should I do?
- I have Mpox: What should I do?
Drug information
- Tylenol 30 reviews
- Acetaminophen 104 reviews
- Excedrin 39 reviews
- Goodys Headache Powders 19 reviews
Related support groups
- Tylenol (210 questions, 232 members)
- Acetaminophen (161 questions, 218 members)
- Excedrin (25 questions, 45 members)
- Goodys Headache Powders (1 questions, 3 members)

AHFS® Patient Medication Information is used with permission. ©2025, the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists, Inc. (ASHP). The ASHP Data is a part of the AHFS Drug Information®️; ASHP is not responsible for the accuracy of transpositions from the original context.