Which ones are stronger & would help with my severe anxiety and panic attacks? Also are the 2mg xanax the same as the 2mg kpins? Please respond as soon as you can.
Thank you
Haley
1mg Xanax vs 2mg Klonopin which is stronger?
Question posted by Anonymous on 17 July 2014
Last updated on 18 August 2022 by Deevidesby0
This question has also been asked and answered here: Klonopin vs Xanax - How are they different?
30 Answers
Deevidesby0
30 Oct 2021
I am trying to come off Xanax. I would rather try something natural like cannabis. It has been proven to help. Me have had sever anxiety disorder since I was in puberty. The only time I remember not having panic attacks was in my 20s and late teens when I experimented with Marijuana. I have been on 5mg of Xanax for 10 years now. And wondering the easiest way to ween off.Kpins do nothing for me.
mmmousemaid
5 Jan 2021
Xanax is one of the weaker but immediate benzo; clonazepam is stronger and takes longer for a different effect; used for epilepsy as well.
MissTracey1972
4 Jan 2021
Hello. I will try my best to answer your question the best I can. Personally, from experience, I've tried Xanax 1mg, and Klonopin 2 mg. I used to think I preferred the Xanax but I changed my mind. I prefer the Clonioin 2mg; it DOES last much longer. The danger with the Xanax, is one minute, you're up and awake, the next, out like a light. And I never felt it coming on. You never do feel it coming on.
debbie171717
13 Jan 2020
Klonopin is longer lasting 1 1.5 day shelf life... stayes in your system longer than xanax at 4 to 8 hrs... Klonopin is alot better for me and my never ending attacks and anxiety... since 24 started... best wishes..Debbie..
subs941
9 June 2019
I am prescribed 2mg Clonazepam (Klonopin) ... Xanax 2mg are fine for anxiety but only laat for 4-6 hours... KLONOPIN has a longer half life and there is no comparison in my opinion... if your really trying to treat anxiety there is no comparison when it comes to that mg... 2mg KLONOPIN are wayyyyy better than Xanax 2mg... now lower doses were talking a different story..but that's my opinion and answer to this question
TodJay
1 June 2019
From what I've read, technically clonazepam is slightly stronger but they are close in potency. I've been prescribed alprazolam in the past, and to me it felt stronger, sometimes, for a short period of time but I've also been on klonopin longer, so I can't make a proper assessment on either. Alprazolam was more effective at inducing a comforting state when lying down and not feeling all the physical symptoms such as my heart thumping hard in my neck but it didn't seem to be as noticeable while up and about as clonazepam is. It was at most times "silent" when it kicked in, sort of like you don't really notice it until you realize you've calmed down from anxiousness within a half an hour to an hour of taking it, and causes this heavy woozy feel around the forehead and eyes for within an hour or 2 after taking before it begins mellow down.
But after that it doesn't really feel like much is happening, and it's made me feel disassociated once or a few times, and it even though I though I was going to sleep nice on it, nights or naps felt crappy, and I've woken up with a stiff neck and/or headache. Clonazepam takes longer for peak effects but lasts longer with less uncomfortable side effects when they do appear.
TrapperDiggs
17 Jan 2019
The issue of strength when comparing Xanax and Klonopin is utterly fruitless unless the question is more guided toward a specific reslve. As it stands this question can only be answered that 2 mg of Klonopin is in fact stronger than 1 mg of Xanax.
My2cents52
9 Oct 2018
Everybody's different, but I take 1 1/2 mg. Xanax for sleep. I've taken 1mg clonazepam for sleep. The reaction time is longer for clonazepam.
NotfadeAway
21 June 2018
I say eat 5g of Mushrooms and say screw the pharmaceutical BS. Ever thought about what folks did before modern day medicine? They visited their local witch doctor or Shaman who in turn took them on a psychedelic experience that will change them for the better. This over prescribing of medicine is what is destroying the collective consciousness of humanity! Fwiw the xanax are stronger. Hope you find some help! Eat more mushrooms
juliecarlstan
15 March 2018
Klonopin is stronger. But! Xanax is fast acting for panic attacks, those are horrible, right?
See Xanax is like ur hyper friend, comes in fast, doesn't stay long.
Klonopin is like a fishing trip, starts slow, low key, and lasts 40 hours. Seriously, 1 dose of klonopin lasts 40 hours, I read in a medical journal that ur not supposed to take it more than 4 months.
But, If u need it, it's super useful. Come to read some of the klonopin withdrawal communes posts?
Patsy Ann
4 March 2018
I can tell you one thing clonazepam cost $275 for 30 day supply Xanax $101 for a 30 day supply you figure it out why would a doctor want to prescribe you the higher end prescription your guess do I trust Dr one or two out of how many
Rjskal
22 April 2018
1mg of Xanax in the generic form, alprazolam, is only around $10/mo. Don’t know where you’re getting $100.
ddknndys
23 Feb 2017
I've been on clonazepam for 7 years, currently 1mg twice daily (BID). I started on 1mg at night and 0.5mg daily as needed for breakthrough (1.5mg a day). Now I take 1.5 mg at night and 0.5mg PRN for breakthrough, so #60 tablets a month. I can tell you from experience and from my psychiatrist's own words: contrary to belief, clonazepam is x2 stronger than alprazolam. It has a higher affinity for the benzo receptors, a longer half life, and because the potency is the same but half life is longer, it is by definition stronger. Xanax can be more recreational because it packs a punch. Think of it as getting the entire dose of Klonopin over 8-12 hours vs 15-30min hour. But, my doc offered to let me try Xanax. I ultimately turned it down but he did say he'd have to give me 4mg of Xanax to keep me comfortable switching from Klonopin. He suggested 3mg Xanax XR and 1mg once daily of Xanax Or for breakthrough.
For me, and every brain is different, I can take 4mg of Klonopin and remember my day/not feel sleepy. 4mg of Xanax won't hold me all day. Definitely stick with Klonopin. Safest, strongest, and easiest to ween. Plus like others said, Xanax is really designed for short term use Or to be used for PRN panick attacks. #klonopin4life
ddknndys
23 Feb 2017
Also every benzo has five main properties of action and each one is stronger in a combination of the five categories. Anxiolytic, anticonvulsant, muscle relaxant, hypnotic/amnesia, and sedative. Clonazepam is a very effective anxiolytic, muscle relaxant, and anticonvulsant. Alprazolam is a stronger hypnotic/amnesia inducing agent as well as anxiolytic. You wouldn't give someone going into a seizure an IV dose of Alprazolam, you'd use Lorazepam or clonazepam. I've heard of epileptics taking 10+ mg of clonazepam a day to control seizure activity. Not sure how you get.out of bed on that dose but some do. I think the FDA will allow max of 6mg/day for GAD/panic but up to 20mg/day for epilepsy.
ddknndys
23 Feb 2017
In general, Clonazepam efficacy drops if you're over 2.5mg. If you find yourself needing more than that, it's time to explore other medications. Over 2.5 and memory/cognitive impairment starts to outweigh benefits except in certain cases.
Mikemeck0723
16 Dec 2016
I have been prescribed to both and tried both at different times and together. It depends on the individual. I think that if you jave no tolerance Klonopin is the was to do. If you take it as prescribed you will rarely run into anxiety thay you can't handle. Xanax is a different animal. It does hit way way harder and way faster. But people say that it dosent last as long is not totally true. If you have no tolerance and take 2mg of Xanax it could knock you out all day compared to if you took 2mgs Klonopin you wouldn't feel it as much and it hits you milder. No benzo withdrawal if you suddenly stop will kick in way faster with Xanax than Klonopin. The problem with both are the tolerances go up quickly. So you might have to take a little bit less for a couple days and then go back to your normal does to feel the same.
It is all about finding the best one for you and if you have a doctor that's willing to let you try both that's the best way to do it and you figure out which one works better for you. Right now I am prescribed to klonopin to come down off of using Xanax for too long. And it's working. But I need to use more Klonopin than Xanax for the same affect. I'm Klonopin is not Time released Klonopin will kick in within a half hour and then maybe kick in for another 15 minutes. Xanax will kick in between 15 and 20 minutes. I hope this helps if you have any questions just ask. My question is it better to see a psychiatrist for this or a regular doctor
LauraDawnSimon678
4 Dec 2016
Definitely the 2 mg. Klonopin is by far stronger than a 1 or even a 2 mg. Xanax due to it's longer half-life.
Writemindedlefty
27 Nov 2018
Wrong. Xanax is THE strongest by far.
Foreveragypsy
24 Oct 2016
If you take Klonopin and you need the quick onset like Xanax gives try chewing up the klonopin. Works for me.
Related topics
klonopin, xanax, anxiety, panic disorder
Further information
Similar questions
Search for questions
Still looking for answers? Try searching for what you seek or ask your own question.
